Engineering Case Study | VET Energy
High-Purity CVD-SiC Raw Material Case Study: From 25 kg Trial Cracking Root-Cause Analysis to a 1.5-Ton Order
Engineering Review: Resolving Post-Growth Flat-Grinding Cracking in PVT SiC Crystal Growth
1. Executive Summary
Key Conclusions and Engineering Results:
- Order Outcome: After completing the initial 25 kg trial and process optimization, a leading semiconductor wafer fab in Taiwan bypassed the planned 100 kg and 300 kg step-up trials and placed a direct purchase order for 1.5 tons of VET Energy high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.
- Root-Cause Identification: Cleavage cracking observed during post-growth flat-grinding of the first ingot was traced not to raw material purity or impurities, but to excessive growth interface curvature and a fast cooling rate causing concentrated release of residual thermal stress.
- Optimization Impact: By flattening the interface curvature, adding an in-situ annealing soak at 2000C-2100C, and leveraging the high packing density of CVD material, post-growth cracking dropped to 0% and crystal height per run increased by 15%.
2. Background and Qualification Roadmap
In physical vapor transport (PVT) silicon carbide (SiC) single-crystal growth, changing the source material directly affects vapor phase species (such as Si, Si2C, and SiC2 partial pressures) and thermal field distribution. As a result, downstream wafer fabs typically follow a strict qualification path for new material suppliers: 25 kg trial run, followed by 100 kg and 300 kg pilot batches, before moving to ton-scale volume orders.
A well-known semiconductor wafer manufacturer in Taiwan focused on high-power and high-frequency device substrates initially ordered 25 kg of VET Energy high-purity CVD-SiC raw material for a first-round PVT growth evaluation. Under the original plan, a smooth 25 kg run would lead to gradual scale-up at 100 kg and 300 kg. Instead, following the initial trial and joint troubleshooting of flat-grinding cracking, the customer skipped the intermediate steps and placed a direct order for 1.5 tons of high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.
3. Issue During the 25 kg Trial: Through-Cracking After Flat-Grinding
After growing the crystal boule with the initial 25 kg batch of CVD material, the as-grown crystal appeared externally sound. However, during downstream processing (top cropping, flat-grinding, and polishing), a failure occurred: the crystal ingot developed through-going cleavage cracks along the crystal plane after flat-grinding.
Dr. Kevin, the customer’s R&D lead, promptly contacted the VET Energy engineering team to report the flat-grinding cracking and investigate the cause.
4. Technical Investigation and Physical Mechanism of Cracking
Working together with the customer, the VET Energy engineering team carried out a systematic investigation:
4.1 Raw Material Quality Traceability: Ruling Out Intrinsic Impurities
The engineering team reviewed SIMS and GDMS quality reports from retained samples of the same batch:
- Shallow Donor and Lattice Distortion Control: Measured nitrogen concentration was below 5e15 atoms/cm3 (approx. 0.05 ppm), transition metals such as Fe, Al, and Ti were below 0.01 ppm, and key trace element W was below 0.02 ppm. Low impurity solubility ruled out lattice distortion stress caused by foreign atom clustering.
- Consistent Vapor Partial Pressure Throughout the Run: VET Energy CVD material offers high packing density (granule size 4-10 mm / 1-30 mm). During high-temperature sublimation, Si/C vapor partial pressure remained near a steady 1:1 ratio, while granules retained their shape without collapse or graphitization, avoiding late-stage carbon enrichment, carbon inclusions, and resulting stress concentration.
4.2 Physical Mechanism: Concentrated Release of Residual Thermal Stress
After ruling out raw material quality issues, the team identified high residual thermal stress accumulated during crystal growth and cooling as the primary cause:
- During the 2200C PVT growth stage, suboptimal axial and radial temperature gradients (dT/dz, dT/dr) resulted in a steep solid-liquid interface curvature, building non-uniform thermal strain inside the crystal.
- Flat-grinding removed the outer stress-balancing layer of the crystal, disturbing the mechanical equilibrium of the system.
- When internal residual shear stress exceeded the critical resolved shear stress of the SiC {0001} plane, instantaneous cleavage cracking occurred along the shear direction.
4.3 Key Quantitative Parameters Requested
To pinpoint the stress source, our engineers requested key process data from the customer:
- Growth interface curvature (center-to-edge height difference): To evaluate whether the solid-liquid interface was overly convex or steep.
- Diameter expansion profile and radial temperature difference: To assess transverse tensile stress during diameter enlargement.
- Cooling and annealing profile: To review high-temperature soak holds and cooling rates.
5. Collaborative Process Optimization and Implementation
Based on the findings of steep interface curvature and rapid cooling, both engineering teams implemented three targeted adjustments:
5.1 Flattening the Solid-Liquid Interface Curvature
Fine-tuned the relative position and power ratio of the upper and lower induction coils in the PVT furnace to lower the radial temperature gradient, shifting a steep convex interface toward a gentler slightly convex profile and reducing center-to-edge thickness variation to lower shear stress buildup at the source.
5.2 Adding High-Temperature In-Situ Annealing and Slower Cooling
Added a 4-to-6-hour in-situ annealing hold at 2000C-2100C after growth to allow thermal relaxation of residual stress through atomic diffusion, and reduced the cooling rate from 6-8C/min to 2-3C/min.
5.3 Leveraging High Packing Density and Stable Sublimation of CVD Material
Taking advantage of non-collapsing, non-graphitizing CVD granules, increased crucible charge weight from 3.5 kg to 5.0 kg (adding more than 1.5-2 kg within the same crucible volume), maintaining steady vapor flux and preventing late-stage source depletion and thermal field drift.
6. Verification Results and Commercial Decision
Using the same 25 kg batch of material with the updated process, the customer achieved strong results:
- Zero Processing Cracking: The grown SiC boules achieved a 0% cracking rate across slicing, flat-grinding, and polishing, meeting semiconductor-grade stress requirements.
- 15% Increase in Crystal Height per Run: Higher charge density and steady sublimation increased per-run crystal height by 15% while reducing carbon inclusion and micropipe density.
- Direct Volume Order: Impressed by both the CVD material performance and collaborative engineering support, the customer's management bypassed the 100 kg and 300 kg pilot stages and placed a direct order for 1.5 tons of high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.
7. VET Energy CVD-SiC Raw Material Comparison
| Comparison Metric | VET Energy CVD-SiC Raw Material | Conventional SHS / Acheson Raw Material |
|---|---|---|
| Purity & Lattice Impurities | Purity ≥99.99995%, W < 0.02 ppm, N < 5e15 cm-3, minimal impurity-induced lattice distortion | Lower purity, higher Fe, Al, and Ti levels, acid-leaching residues prone to stress concentration |
| Granule Size & Charge Density | Large granules (1-30 mm / 4-10 mm), high packing density, +1.5-2.0 kg more charge in same crucible volume for thicker boules | Smaller particles (<2.5 mm), lower packing density, higher risk of late-stage depletion and thermal drift |
| Sublimation & Vapor Stability | Granules hold shape without collapse, near 1:1 Si/C vapor ratio, no graphitization, low carbon inclusion risk | Prone to graphitization and collapse at high temperature, Si-rich early and C-rich later, higher carbon inclusion and micropipe risk |
| Engineering & Technical Support | End-to-end PVT growth support including thermal field tuning, interface curvature review, and annealing curve optimization | Primarily bulk commodity supply without dedicated PVT thermal field or process diagnostics |
8. Conclusion and Sample Inquiries
VET Energy provides high-purity materials and engineering support for the global semiconductor industry. Beyond supplying high-purity CVD-SiC raw material, our technical team assists customers with material matching, thermal field diagnostics, and stress mitigation.
If your team is addressing flat-grinding cracking, carbon inclusions, high micropipe density, or late-run growth rate drop in 6-inch or 8-inch SiC crystal growth, reach out to our engineering team for sample evaluation and technical support.
VET Energy Samples and Technical Inquiries
VET Energy
Website: www.vet-china.com
Phone: +86-0574-86503782 / +86-189 1159 6392
Email: yeah@china-vet.com
Address: No. 777 Zhongguan West Road, Zhuangshi Subdistrict, Zhenhai District, Ningbo, Zhejiang, China
Post time: Nov-19-2026