High-Purity CVD-SiC Raw Material Case Study: Resolving Flat-Grinding Cracking in PVT SiC Growth

Engineering Case Study | VET Energy

High-Purity CVD-SiC Raw Material Case Study: From 25 kg Trial Cracking Root-Cause Analysis to a 1.5-Ton Order

Engineering Review: Resolving Post-Growth Flat-Grinding Cracking in PVT SiC Crystal Growth

Keywords: CVD SiC Raw Material | PVT Crystal Growth | Thermal Stress | Flat-Grinding Cracking | Solid-Liquid Interface Curvature | Annealing Profile | VET Energy

1. Executive Summary

Key Conclusions and Engineering Results:

  • Order Outcome: After completing the initial 25 kg trial and process optimization, a leading semiconductor wafer fab in Taiwan bypassed the planned 100 kg and 300 kg step-up trials and placed a direct purchase order for 1.5 tons of VET Energy high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.
  • Root-Cause Identification: Cleavage cracking observed during post-growth flat-grinding of the first ingot was traced not to raw material purity or impurities, but to excessive growth interface curvature and a fast cooling rate causing concentrated release of residual thermal stress.
  • Optimization Impact: By flattening the interface curvature, adding an in-situ annealing soak at 2000C-2100C, and leveraging the high packing density of CVD material, post-growth cracking dropped to 0% and crystal height per run increased by 15%.

2. Background and Qualification Roadmap

In physical vapor transport (PVT) silicon carbide (SiC) single-crystal growth, changing the source material directly affects vapor phase species (such as Si, Si2C, and SiC2 partial pressures) and thermal field distribution. As a result, downstream wafer fabs typically follow a strict qualification path for new material suppliers: 25 kg trial run, followed by 100 kg and 300 kg pilot batches, before moving to ton-scale volume orders.

A well-known semiconductor wafer manufacturer in Taiwan focused on high-power and high-frequency device substrates initially ordered 25 kg of VET Energy high-purity CVD-SiC raw material for a first-round PVT growth evaluation. Under the original plan, a smooth 25 kg run would lead to gradual scale-up at 100 kg and 300 kg. Instead, following the initial trial and joint troubleshooting of flat-grinding cracking, the customer skipped the intermediate steps and placed a direct order for 1.5 tons of high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.

3. Issue During the 25 kg Trial: Through-Cracking After Flat-Grinding

After growing the crystal boule with the initial 25 kg batch of CVD material, the as-grown crystal appeared externally sound. However, during downstream processing (top cropping, flat-grinding, and polishing), a failure occurred: the crystal ingot developed through-going cleavage cracks along the crystal plane after flat-grinding.

Dr. Kevin, the customer’s R&D lead, promptly contacted the VET Energy engineering team to report the flat-grinding cracking and investigate the cause.

4. Technical Investigation and Physical Mechanism of Cracking

Working together with the customer, the VET Energy engineering team carried out a systematic investigation:

4.1 Raw Material Quality Traceability: Ruling Out Intrinsic Impurities

The engineering team reviewed SIMS and GDMS quality reports from retained samples of the same batch:

  • Shallow Donor and Lattice Distortion Control: Measured nitrogen concentration was below 5e15 atoms/cm3 (approx. 0.05 ppm), transition metals such as Fe, Al, and Ti were below 0.01 ppm, and key trace element W was below 0.02 ppm. Low impurity solubility ruled out lattice distortion stress caused by foreign atom clustering.
  • Consistent Vapor Partial Pressure Throughout the Run: VET Energy CVD material offers high packing density (granule size 4-10 mm / 1-30 mm). During high-temperature sublimation, Si/C vapor partial pressure remained near a steady 1:1 ratio, while granules retained their shape without collapse or graphitization, avoiding late-stage carbon enrichment, carbon inclusions, and resulting stress concentration.

4.2 Physical Mechanism: Concentrated Release of Residual Thermal Stress

After ruling out raw material quality issues, the team identified high residual thermal stress accumulated during crystal growth and cooling as the primary cause:

  • During the 2200C PVT growth stage, suboptimal axial and radial temperature gradients (dT/dz, dT/dr) resulted in a steep solid-liquid interface curvature, building non-uniform thermal strain inside the crystal.
  • Flat-grinding removed the outer stress-balancing layer of the crystal, disturbing the mechanical equilibrium of the system.
  • When internal residual shear stress exceeded the critical resolved shear stress of the SiC {0001} plane, instantaneous cleavage cracking occurred along the shear direction.

4.3 Key Quantitative Parameters Requested

To pinpoint the stress source, our engineers requested key process data from the customer:

  • Growth interface curvature (center-to-edge height difference): To evaluate whether the solid-liquid interface was overly convex or steep.
  • Diameter expansion profile and radial temperature difference: To assess transverse tensile stress during diameter enlargement.
  • Cooling and annealing profile: To review high-temperature soak holds and cooling rates.

5. Collaborative Process Optimization and Implementation

Based on the findings of steep interface curvature and rapid cooling, both engineering teams implemented three targeted adjustments:

5.1 Flattening the Solid-Liquid Interface Curvature

Fine-tuned the relative position and power ratio of the upper and lower induction coils in the PVT furnace to lower the radial temperature gradient, shifting a steep convex interface toward a gentler slightly convex profile and reducing center-to-edge thickness variation to lower shear stress buildup at the source.

5.2 Adding High-Temperature In-Situ Annealing and Slower Cooling

Added a 4-to-6-hour in-situ annealing hold at 2000C-2100C after growth to allow thermal relaxation of residual stress through atomic diffusion, and reduced the cooling rate from 6-8C/min to 2-3C/min.

5.3 Leveraging High Packing Density and Stable Sublimation of CVD Material

Taking advantage of non-collapsing, non-graphitizing CVD granules, increased crucible charge weight from 3.5 kg to 5.0 kg (adding more than 1.5-2 kg within the same crucible volume), maintaining steady vapor flux and preventing late-stage source depletion and thermal field drift.

6. Verification Results and Commercial Decision

Using the same 25 kg batch of material with the updated process, the customer achieved strong results:

  • Zero Processing Cracking: The grown SiC boules achieved a 0% cracking rate across slicing, flat-grinding, and polishing, meeting semiconductor-grade stress requirements.
  • 15% Increase in Crystal Height per Run: Higher charge density and steady sublimation increased per-run crystal height by 15% while reducing carbon inclusion and micropipe density.
  • Direct Volume Order: Impressed by both the CVD material performance and collaborative engineering support, the customer's management bypassed the 100 kg and 300 kg pilot stages and placed a direct order for 1.5 tons of high-purity CVD-SiC raw material.

7. VET Energy CVD-SiC Raw Material Comparison

Comparison Metric VET Energy CVD-SiC Raw Material Conventional SHS / Acheson Raw Material
Purity & Lattice Impurities Purity ≥99.99995%, W < 0.02 ppm, N < 5e15 cm-3, minimal impurity-induced lattice distortion Lower purity, higher Fe, Al, and Ti levels, acid-leaching residues prone to stress concentration
Granule Size & Charge Density Large granules (1-30 mm / 4-10 mm), high packing density, +1.5-2.0 kg more charge in same crucible volume for thicker boules Smaller particles (<2.5 mm), lower packing density, higher risk of late-stage depletion and thermal drift
Sublimation & Vapor Stability Granules hold shape without collapse, near 1:1 Si/C vapor ratio, no graphitization, low carbon inclusion risk Prone to graphitization and collapse at high temperature, Si-rich early and C-rich later, higher carbon inclusion and micropipe risk
Engineering & Technical Support End-to-end PVT growth support including thermal field tuning, interface curvature review, and annealing curve optimization Primarily bulk commodity supply without dedicated PVT thermal field or process diagnostics

8. Conclusion and Sample Inquiries

VET Energy provides high-purity materials and engineering support for the global semiconductor industry. Beyond supplying high-purity CVD-SiC raw material, our technical team assists customers with material matching, thermal field diagnostics, and stress mitigation.

If your team is addressing flat-grinding cracking, carbon inclusions, high micropipe density, or late-run growth rate drop in 6-inch or 8-inch SiC crystal growth, reach out to our engineering team for sample evaluation and technical support.

VET Energy Samples and Technical Inquiries

VET Energy

Website: www.vet-china.com

Phone: +86-0574-86503782 / +86-189 1159 6392

Email: yeah@china-vet.com

Address: No. 777 Zhongguan West Road, Zhuangshi Subdistrict, Zhenhai District, Ningbo, Zhejiang, China


Post time: Nov-19-2026
WhatsApp Online Chat !